Staff Ranking Results - Raw

ID Project Name Staff 1 Staff 2 Staff 3 Staff 4 Staff 5 Staff 6 Average
ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION blank blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
A-1 Parking in Bike Lane: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 5 16 7 4 2 10 7.333333333
A-2 Separated Bike/Pedestrian Paths Plan 17 15 10 12 12 11 12.83333333
A-3 Pedestrian Safety Review 18 17 18 11 13 16 15.5
LAND USE, ENVIRONMENT, AND ECONOMY blank blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD
($40,000-$60,000)
7 4 9 14 4 5 7.166666667
ROADWAY AND MULTIMODAL MOBILITY blank blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
M-1 Lab and Municipal Parking Phase II
($60,000-$80,000)
6 6 12 2 11 9 7.666666667
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 3 1 4 3 5 14 5
TRANSIT blank blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
T-1 Effective ways to reduce school-related vehicle trips
($60,000-$80,000)
15 8 1 15 8 15 10.33333333
T-2 Review and Analysis of Community Connections Shuttles
($40,000-$60,000)
10 9 13 5 18 3 9.666666667
T-3 Toward Regional Transit Fare and Service Integration
($40,000-$60,000)
16 3 2 1 7 13 7
T-4 Mapping Fixed-Route Service 4 2 17 17 10 18 11.33333333
T-5 Modeling Factors that Affect Transit Usage 14 14 15 16 14 7 13.33333333
T-6 Demographic Change and Transit Propensity in Eastern MA 11 10 16 10 17 8 12
T-7 Review of and Lessons From Transit Capital Construction Costs Research 13 18 14 13 16 4 13
RESILIENCE blank blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
R-1 Modeling Evacuation Routes
($80,000-$100,000)
9 5 11 6 6 12 8.166666667
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement
($20,000-$40,000)
1 13 3 7 1 2 4.5
R-3 MPO Support for Transportation Network Electrification
($50,000)
2 11 5 9 9 6 7
TRANSIT EQUITY blank blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring
($70,000)
8 7 8 8 3 1 5.833333333
TE-2 Identifying Transit Options in Underserved Areas 12 12 6 18 15 17 13.33333333

17 Total study concepts

 

 

Staff Ranking Results - Average

ID Project Name Average
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement
($20,000-$40,000)
4.5
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 5
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring
($70,000)
5.8
T-3 Toward Regional Transit Fare and Service Integration
($40,000-$60,000)
7
R-3 MPO Support for Transportation Network Electrification
($50,000)
7
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD
($40,000-$60,000)
7.2
A-1 Parking in Bike Lane: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 7.3
M-1 Lab and Municipal Parking Phase II
($60,000-$80,000)
7.6
R-1 Modeling Evacuation Routes
($80,000-$100,000)
8.2
T-2 Review and Analysis of Community Connections Shuttles
($40,000-$60,000)
9.6
T-1 Effective ways to reduce school-related vehicle trips
($60,000-$80,000)
10.3
T-4 Mapping Fixed-Route Service 11.3
T-6 Demographic Change and Transit Propensity in Eastern MA 12
A-2 Separated Bike/Pedestrian Paths Plan 12.8
T-7 Review of and Lessons From Transit Capital Construction Costs Research 13
T-5 Modeling Factors that Affect Transit Usage 13.3
A-3 Pedestrian Safety Review 15.5
TE-2 Identifying Transit Options in Underserved Areas 17

18 Total study concepts

 

 

Committee Ranking Results - Raw

ID Project Name MassDOT OTP Regional Transportation Advisory Council Metroplitan Area Planning Council Inner Core Committee/City of Somerville At-Large City of Newton Average
ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
A-1 Parking in Bike Lane: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 15 2 6 14 6 8.6
A-2 Separated Bike/Pedestrian Paths Plan 6 8 2 7 8 6.2
A-3 Pedestrian Safety Inventory 9 7 7 15 9 9.4
LAND USE, ENVIRONMENT, AND ECONOMY blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD
($40,000-$60,000)
5 14 8 10 12 9.8
ROADWAY AND MULTIMODAL MOBILITY blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
M-1 Lab and Municipal Parking Phase II
($60,000-$80,000)
1 17 4 6 10 7.6
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 18 16 9 11 17 14.2
TRANSIT blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
T-1 Effective ways to reduce school-related vehicle trips
($60,000-$80,000)
3 6 3 4 1 3.4
T-2 Review and Analysis of Community Connections Shuttles
($40,000-$60,000)
17 5 1 5 15 8.6
T-3 Toward Regional Transit Fare and Service Integration
($40,000-$60,000)
7 1 10 8 2 5.6
T-4 Mapping Fixed-Route Service 4 4 5 17 7 7.4
T-5 Modeling Factors that Affect Transit Usage 11 12 11 16 11 12.2
T-6 Demographic Change and Transit Propensity in Eastern MA 12 10 12 12 3 9.8
T-7 Review of and Lessons From Transit Capital Construction Costs Research 13 18 13 9 4 11.4
RESILIENCE blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
R-1 Modeling Evacuation Routes
($80,000-$100,000)
8 15 14 18 16 14.2
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement
($20,000-$40,000)
14 11 15 2 13 11
R-3 MPO Support for Transportation Network Electrification
($50,000)
2 13 16 3 5 7.8
TRANSIT EQUITY blank blank blank blank blank blank blank
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring
($70,000)
16 3 17 1 14 10.2
TE-2 Identifying Transit Options in Underserved Areas 10 9 18 13 18 13.6

17 Total study concepts

 

 

Committee Ranking Results - Average

ID Project Name Average
T-1 Effective ways to reduce school-related vehicle trips
($60,000-$80,000)
3.4
T-3 Toward Regional Transit Fare and Service Integration
($40,000-$60,000)
5.6
A-2 Separated Bike/Pedestrian Paths Plan 6.2
T-4 Mapping Fixed-Route Service 7.4
M-1 Lab and Municipal Parking Phase II
($60,000-$80,000)
7.6
R-3 MPO Support for Transportation Network Electrification
($50,000)
7.8
A-1 Parking in Bike Lane: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 8.6
T-2 Review and Analysis of Community Connections Shuttles
($40,000-$60,000)
8.6
A-3 Pedestrian Safety Inventory 9.4
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD
($40,000-$60,000)
9.8
T-6 Demographic Change and Transit Propensity in Eastern MA 9.8
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring
($70,000)
10.2
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement
($20,000-$40,000)
11
T-7 Review of and Lessons From Transit Capital Construction Costs Research 11.4
T-5 Modeling Factors that Affect Transit Usage 12.2
TE-2 Identifying Transit Options in Underserved Areas 13.6
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 14.2
R-1 Modeling Evacuation Routes
($80,000-$100,000)
14.2

18 Total study concepts

 

Staff Recommended Studies

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring 5.8 10.2
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 5 14.2
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD 7.2 9.8
M-1 Lab and Municipal Parking Phase II 7.6 7.6
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11
A-1 Parking in Bike Lanes: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 7.3 8.6

 

 

Draft Scenarios

Scenario 1

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)  Cost 
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11  $      35,000.00
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 5 14.2  $      55,000.00
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring 5.8 10.2  $      60,000.00
Total Cost  $   150,000.00

 

Scenario 2

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)  Cost 
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11  $      35,000.00
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring 5.8 10.2  $      70,000.00
A-1 Parking in Bike Lanes: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 7.3 8.6  $      45,000.00
Total Cost  $   150,000.00

 

Scenario 3

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)  Cost 
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11  $      20,000.00
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 5 14.2  $      30,000.00
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring 5.8 10.2  $      60,000.00
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD 7.2 9.8  $      40,000.00
Total Cost  $   150,000.00

 

Scenario 4

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)  Cost 
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11  $      30,000.00
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring 5.8 10.2  $      65,000.00
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD 7.2 9.8  $      55,000.00
Total Cost  $   150,000.00

 

Scenario 5

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)  Cost 
A-1 Parking in Bike Lanes: Strategies for Safety and Prevention 7.3 8.6  $      20,000.00
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD 7.2 9.8  $      40,000.00
M-1 Lab and Municipal Parking Phase II 7.6 7.6  $      70,000.00
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11  $      20,000.00
Total Cost  $   150,000.00

 

Scenario 6

Code Title Ranking (Staff) Ranking (Committee)  Cost 
TE-1 Applying Conveyal to TIP Project Scoring 5.8 10.2  $      55,000.00
M-2 Exploring Roadway Pricing: Engagement with Local Stakeholders 5 14.2  $      35,000.00
L-1 Opportunities for the MPO to Support TOD 7.2 9.8  $      35,000.00
R-2 Strategies for Environmental Outreach and Engagement 4.5 11  $      25,000.00
Total Cost  $   150,000.00